Showing posts with label Series 03. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Series 03. Show all posts

Tuesday, 25 December 2018

Missing Episodes analysis

UPDATED 8 Apr 2024


Well, there's fan telesnaps recons of all of them and 16mm telecines of some of them.
These days there's Animated eps on DVD and fan animations. Some are better than others.
For reference, here's the scoreboard


A  BBC DVD Animation
A   Fan animation with full motion and basically watchable with narrative integrity (incomplete ep animations not counted.)

R  BBC DVD reconstruction using telesnaps (not necessarily perfect, fan recons are often better)

 -   It's missing



No. TITLE






001 1A An Unearthly Child 1 2 3 4


002 1B The Dead Planet 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
003 1C Beyond the Sun 1 2 3 4


004 1D Marco Polo A  -   -   -   -   -   - 
005 1E The Keys of Marinus 1 2 3 4 5 6
006 1F The Aztecs 1 2 3 4


007 1G The Sensorites 1 2 3 4 5 6
008 1H The French Revolution 1 2 3 A A 6
009 1J Planet of Giants 1 2 3



010 1K The World's End 1 2 3 4 5 6
011 1L The Powerful Enemy 1 2




012 1M The Romans 1 2 3 4


013 1N The Web Planet 1 2 3 4 5 6
014 1P The Lion 1 R 3 R


015 1Q The Space Museum 1 2 3 4


016 1R The Executioners 1 2 3 4 5 6
017 1S The Time Meddler 1 2 3 4


018 1T Galaxy Four A A 3 A A


019 1T/A Mission to the Unknown A





020 1U The Mythmakers  -   -   -   - 


021  1V The Daleks Masterplan  -  2  -   -  5  -   - 




A  -   -   -   10  -   - 
022 1W The Massacre  -   -   -   - 


023 1X The Ark 1 2 3 4


024 1Y The Celestial Toymaker A A A 4 A


025 1Z The Gunfighters 1 2 3 4


026 2A The Savages  -   -   -   - 


027 2B The War Machines 1 2 3 4


028 2C The Smugglers  -   -   -   - 


029 2D The Tenth Planet 1 2 3 A


030 2E The Power of the Daleks A A A A A A
031 2F The Highlanders  -   -   -   - 


032 2G The Underwater Menace A 2 A 3 A A


033 2H The Moonbase A 2 A 4


034 2J The Macra Terror A A A A


035 2K The Faceless Ones 1 A A 3 A A A A
036 2L The Evil of the Daleks A 2 A A A A A A
037 2M The Tomb of the Cybermen 1 2 3 4


038 2N The Abominable Snowmen A 2 A A A A A
039 2O The Ice Warriors 1 A A 4 5 6
040 2P The Enemy of the World 1 2 3 4 5 6
041 2Q The Web of Fear 1 2 A 4 5 6
042 2R Fury from the Deep A A A A A A
043 2S The Wheel in Space  -   -  3  -   -  6
044 2T The Dominators 1 2 3 4 5

045 2U The Mind Robber 1 2 3 4 5

046 2V The Invasion A 2 3 A




5 6 7 8


047 2W The Krotons 1 2 3 4



048 2X The Seeds of Death 1 2 3 4 5 6
049 2Y The Space Pirates  -  2  -   -   -   - 
050 2Z The War Games 1 2 3 4 5



6 7 8 9 10



Eps Complete Serials
TOTAL 253 50
OK - 156 - 24
MISSING = 97 = 26
BBC ANIMATED - 50 - 15
Fan animated - 3 -1
Really missing = 44 = 10

Saturday, 18 August 2018

027 The War Machines

Started 18-Aug

This has aged horribly.

It is clearly a prototype UNIT story. It is the first story wholly set in 'the present day'. There is a different feel to this story. It's modern and eschews established convention.

It seems decidedly odd to see William Hartnell's Doctor acting as 'Scientific Adviser" and getting all 'matey' with establishment types like Summers and the 'minister'. If this was Pertwee you'd believe it. Verity Lambert would have stopped this happening, I reckon.

While Prof Brett, Col. Green and Sir Reginald are very conservative characters, Ben and Polly are cheeky and irreverent in a way that looks starkly new. I cannot imagine Ian and Barbara talking like they do.

But the Inferno /hottest night spot in town seems twee.

The concept of hooking up computers across the world (about a dozen of 'em) by telephone is presented as "wowee".  This seems laughably naive in 2018.

The way WOTAN takes over people in ep1 is staged like a primitive religious ceremony. One thing that maybe hasn't changed so much is the fear of the 'big', sneaky technology. You can still read/see news stories today about how computers are gonna take over the world soon (or something like it.) The premise of the War Machines story plays on this primordial notion.


The guff about computers 'thinking' is obviously wrong. What computer technology allows people to do is the same evil but more efficiently and comprehensively. If the script of The War Machines had realised this it might have been 20 times better as a story.


The script mistake of WOTAN referring to "Doctor Who" is disappointing but it's hardly the worst aspect of this.

From somewhere in the middle of ep2 this goes seriously off the rails in drama terms. The characters are very underdeveloped and seem horribly cliched, especially the soldiers and the other goodies. The way Brett and Krimpton seem to stare upward into the middle distance and soliloquise about what the nasty computer is gonna do is very strange. Who exactly are they meant to be telling this stuff? Is it computer instructions? Greek chorus? Or narration? It does not work.

Several ludicrous things happen in the plot e.g the 'dosser' (who takes taxis and has brand new shoes... huh?) is attacked and presumably murdered late at night by the War Machine workers and yet the Summers and the Doctor casually read about it in the newspaper the **next** morning. Nah.... that's Silver Nemesis silly.

There's a lot of visual flourishes in this which are impressive: The war machines on film on location in city streets is the obvious, repeated one. The machines are a bit limited to crashing through piles of boxes but the director manages to make it look exciting... somehow. This kind of thing is destined for repetition on DW but here it is very style over substance.

This story is a bold, fresh, new style in DW. It's the start of 'the yeti on the loo' monsters. It's the start of modern contemporary DW stories (which they're still doing in 2017.) Give it another year and this idea will become Web of Fear and Fury from the Deep. But this early prototype is a bit lame looking 52 years on.

ABM Rating 2.05/4.00
LJM Rating 3.00/5.00
SPJ Rating 5.00/10.00  

No. 18 (out of 27)

Link to Cumulative Rankings


Rankings Scoreboard

Tuesday, 14 August 2018

026 The Savages

Started 14-Aug-2018

Series 3 has been rocky. An ugly start, a Dalek powered soar in the air, some historical dullness, weird (bizarre?) forays into the experimental and (as of next serial) a genuine revolution in DW storytelling.

But in the meantime...
The Savages is a delightful surprise. And Bill is fantastic as the Doctor in this.


The first serial with numbered episodes....

We watched a LC recon. This has genuine telesnaps unlike recent missing eps serials which are recreated from publicity photos and other studio images.  Reason is the new production team started ordering John Cura telesnaps once again from The Gunfighters onwards and these were discovered in the BBC Written Archives by Marcus Hearn (now DWM editor again) in the early 90's...

Two eps in this seems a much more sophisticated SF story than anything this series so far.
The characters are genuinely 'shades of grey' duplicitous and have stealthy motives. Dramatically it is intriguing and the political themes (supremacism, eugenics, bio-engineering) mark a fresh dawn of sophisticated SF for DW.  Is this Davis and Pedler at work? I wonder...

The music in this is by Raymond Jones (whose only other credit is The Romans). It seems ambitious and insistent and noticeable. It's good but maybe it seems that way after the 'Ballad...'.

This is a story I had not previously appreciated. Poor quality soundtracks and tedious telesnaps are a barrier even for rolled gold fans I guess.

Easy no 2 for series 3.


ABM Rating 3.15/4.00
LJM Rating 3.75/5.00
SPJ Rating 7.00/10.00   

No. 5 (out of 26)

Link to Cumulative Rankings


Rankings Scoreboard

Thursday, 9 August 2018

025 The Gunfighters

Started 9-Aug

Brightly comic with pithy lines. Quite unconvincing as a western but clearly the intention is to satirise westerns.

Johnny Ringo is Shane.
Doc Holliday and Wyatt Earp are western legends. The shootout at the OK Corrall is too. The actual history in this story is pretty ropey (apparently).

This teleplay is having fun with trope-y toys. Conceptually it's actually a little like kid's play with different brands, types and ranges of toys... like Barbie on the Star Wars Millenium Falcon action figures set or My Little Pony with bendy dinosaurs.

A point I've made before about this one is that watched in 2018 these episodes are shorn of the context of popular TV at the time this was made. TV westerns were in the early to mid 60's what Celebrity Cooking Shows are like these days. Back then there were many of them, the most popular TV shows were Westerns, so were lots of the less popular ones. When Dr Who was first shown in Australia on ABC channel 2 in 1965 the bill was 7pm The News, 7.30pm Dr Who, 7.55pm Tales of Wells Fargo. These days we have the idea that 60's telly was corny sitcoms and spies and detectives. Well it was. But it was also westerns....

The Gunfighters is a parody of the high budget US filmed TV western series.

Specifically,
....there's dozens of 'em... and all make The Gunfighters look stupid, cheap and a bad idea. Fake British "American" accents (except Shane Rimmer as Seth Harper who doing a fake Canadian "American" accent), studio lighting and video and the wimping out with gun play are competing with film, real horses, genuine western Hollywood chutzpah.

Which is why it had a bad reputation at the time. Here's a hard fact. Ep4 of this serial "The OK Corral" Audience Appreciation score was 30%  To this day that's the lowest,  last place, bottom of the barrel. Clearly the audience of 1966 saw this as a poor quality fake.

These days the western doesn't exist. No one reads 'em, no one makes 'em, even die hard fans are hard to find (DW fans aren't remarkable they are exceptional!!). The nearest to a popular Western show is HBO's Deadwood and that's more like Game of Thrones than Rawhide.

Might be tempted to say Gunfighters was bad then, it's still bad and therefore it's bad. But I think there is something tragicomic going on.

The tone in this seems jokey with an undercurrent of menace. This is a weird mixture. When you add the repetitious song with it's narrative elements the story takes on a almost operatic tragedian aspect.


Except that it ISN'T.... it's The Gunfighters. A silly experimental Series 3 DW serial that was lucky to get made, survives only through dumb luck, the other experiments that surround it having rather worse luck at surviving.

Is it good Doctor Who? The end of ep2 when Johnny Ringo makes his dramatic entrance is attractive and ominous but the DW theme music cuts against it really strainfully. So, that's a no....

Luckily this is the LAST Wiles/Tosh hangover script. From here it's all Lloyd and Davis's own work.... and it's about to swing.

Warning for where we're going. We haven't had a 'base under siege' story yet. When we start you'll have plenty of chance to get used to it.


ABM Rating 2.19/4.00
LJM Rating 1.50/5.00
SPJ Rating 2.50/10.00


No. 23 (out of 25)

Link to Cumulative Rankings


Rankings Scoreboard